Balancer Proposes Protocol Wind-Down Amid Revenue Struggles

Balancer, a prominent decentralized exchange (DEX) and automated market maker (AMM), has put forth a proposal to initiate an orderly wind-down of its protocol. This decision stems from a failure to revitalize revenue streams despite significant restructuring and product development efforts undertaken after a major security incident. The proposal, authored by Balancer Labs CEO Marcus Hardt, suggests distributing the protocol's remaining treasury assets to BAL token holders.

The core of the issue lies in Balancer's inability to generate adequate revenue, particularly from its newer v3 architecture, which has not offset the decline in income from its legacy v2 protocol. While restructuring successfully reduced operational costs and delivered promised products, the crucial revenue targets were not met. Hardt noted that most of the protocol's current income still derives from v2, indicating that v3's adoption and revenue-generating capacity have fallen short of expectations.

The proposal follows Balancer Labs' previous decision to shut down its operational entity in March, transitioning to a leaner structure. However, the impact of a substantial $128 million exploit in November 2025 on its composable stable pools continued to cast a long shadow. Hardt admitted to underestimating the extent to which this past security event would hinder user adoption and dampen market confidence, making it difficult for the v3 platform to gain traction.

Data from DeFiLlama illustrates the stark revenue decline, with monthly protocol revenue dropping from $1.13 million in October 2025 to $371,000 in November following the exploit. This downward trend persisted into 2026, with August revenue figures reaching a low of just $56,781. This significant decrease underscores the challenge Balancer faced in reviving its financial viability.

The proposed wind-down process involves a phased shutdown beginning next month, with an end to new business development and a deadline of October 30 for liquidity providers to exit. Pools that can be paused will transition to withdrawal-only mode, while others will operate with zero protocol fees where technically feasible. By November 1, the protocol would focus solely on supporting asset withdrawals, with the Decentralized Autonomous Organization (DAO) being dissolved.

Following the operational wind-down, the remaining treasury, currently valued at over $9 million, is slated for distribution to BAL token holders on a pro-rata basis. The initial distribution is planned for May 2027, requiring holders to burn their BAL tokens in exchange for their share of the treasury assets. Subsequent distributions will cover any unspent wind-down funds and unclaimed assets, with a final sweep to occur six months later.

The decision to propose a wind-down reflects a pragmatic approach, as continuing operations without sufficient revenue would merely deplete the treasury without altering the ultimate outcome. Hardt argued that it is more beneficial for BAL holders to receive a substantial portion of the treasury while it remains significant, rather than see it spent on a strategy that has not proven effective. The proposal now awaits approval from BAL token holders through a snapshot vote scheduled from September 25 to 29.

Market participants will be closely monitoring the upcoming governance vote to determine the future of Balancer. Should the proposal be rejected, the protocol will continue under its existing framework. Traders and investors should observe the discussions around the vote and consider the potential implications for BAL token holders and the broader DeFi landscape, particularly concerning the long-term sustainability of AMM protocols facing revenue pressures and security concerns.

---

Source: Cointelegraph. Summarized and rewritten by the Vexoda Newsroom. This is market news, not financial advice.